Amish Cooking….

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast)

Freda Yoder is the wife of an Amish bishop in Inola, Oklahoma, a small, somewhat progressive Amish settlement that is part of the larger community of Chouteau.  I first came into contact with Freda when working on our cookbook, Amish Cooks Across America. Chouteau’s Amish community is the largest and oldest in the Sooner State, a place that has had a small Amish presence for years. I recently received a copy of Freda’s own cookbook (which she wasn’t shy in promoting to me:).   I’m not in the habit of promoting the cookbooks of others, but I thought it would be fun for a change. Her book is entitled simply “Home Cookin” from The Amish Church of Chouteau, Oklahoma. Freda’s cookbook is a compilation of recipes from the community and in many ways it is a typical softcover Amish style packed with hundreds of recipes, many of them for old-favorites like monster cookies, cinnamon rolls, and soft pretzels.

There are some recipes that made me chuckle, as in “how did this find it’s way into an Amish cookbook?”, namely the “Red Lobster cheese biscuits” and recipe for “Red Lobster cheddary bay biscuits.”  Someone there obviously has a taste for the seafood lover in them.

Oklahoma is situated in a prime position to catch the wave of Hispanic culinary influence infusing itself into Amish cooking and that is reflected in the cookbook.  Recipes like chicken fajita pizza, taco skillet meal, Mexican chicken lasagna, southwest chicken rice casserole, and cheesy enchiladas.appear alongside traditional Amish favorites like potato haystacks, grilled pork chops, and dairy casserole.  Also, true to Oklahoma’s culinary tradition as a haven for amazing barbecue, the book is packed with a lot of great-sounding barbecue recipes.  To purchase a copy of the book, send $20 (that covers shipping) to:

Freda Yoder

9621 West, 600 Road

Inola, OKlahoma, 74036

She sends them by media rate and she’s a busy woman, so expect to wait a month to get your book.  Some of the recipes have massive ingredient quantities (40 pounds of potatoes in one recipe!), but those are needed at large Amish church gatherings.  Most of the recipes are geared towards smaller crowds, thankfully.  A few recipes are really spare on instructions, but that is some of the fun of Amish cooking.

Here are a couple of recipes from the book:


3 pounds sausage, crumbled

8 large potatoes

2 quarts peas

2 small onions

1 tablespoon salt

1 teaspoon pepper

2 cans cream of mushroom soup

4 cans water

1 cup grated cheese

Brown sausage and onions in a frying pan.  Peel and slice potatoes thinly.  Put the meat and vegetables in a roaster.  Mix soup and water with salt and pepper and pour over the meat and vegetable mixture.  Top with cheese.  Bake at 350 for 1 hour covered and then uncover and bake 1 more hour until the potatoes are done.


2 cups cream

1 /2 cup flour

1 cup sugar

Mix the sugar and flour, then add cream. Beat well.  Bake in an unbaked pie crust at 350 until firm.


Join Our Newsletter

Join over 7,000 people who get free and fresh content delivered automatically each time we publish.

Sign Up

The Discussion

  1. Thanks, Kevin. I love these kinds of books. It reminds me of the old Grange and church cookbooks both of my grandmother’s had recipes in years ago in Pennsylvania. I have Sherry Gore’s cookbook also. I am looking forward to your Amish Cook’s Across America and your novel. I like buying books directly from someone like the woman mentioned above. I also bought Marlene C. Miller’s book, “Grace Leads Me Home” directly from her.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
  2. Deanna Schroeder says:

    Just traveled through Choteau this week. Our bus tour had lunch at the Miller’s farmhouse and then we visited the Amish cheese store in Choteau. I highly recommend this shop and will return again on my own. Such a great variety of products: all kinds of cheese, noodles, pickles, homemade breads, etc.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
  3. Manfred Nissley says:

    Hi! I am doing research on this family as I am writing a genealogy book. I enjoyed your documentation of who this lady is. Her husband is my fourth cousin. I have 5 children listed for them, do you happen to know if they have more than that? It also appears her husband may be a genealogist. Is that correct?

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Speak Your Mind


6 × nine =

CommentLuv badge