By Kevin Williams
On Sunday, Aster and I had a “Daddy-Daughter” day and it was a lot of fun. I took her to the annual Dayton Train Show at Hara Arena on the city’s west side. Aster loved the assortment of model trains on display and chugging along for all to enjoy inside. But it was what was outside that really stuck with me.
I’ve lived in southwest Ohio my whole life and I’m not sure I had ever been to this corner of Dayton and what I saw seemed like a ghost town. Just in one pass down Shiloh Springs Road I saw a boarded up former Target, a Lowes sitting empty,a Sears, a JCPenny and other “big box” stores I couldn’t identify. A few chains stores seem to be clinging to life: a Home Depot and a Burlingon Coat Factory, but beyond that…just an empty retail wasteland. Hara Arena, itself, just down the street seemed like it had seen better days also. The facility, still used for concerts and exhibitions, seemed run-down and dumpy.
So, what happened? I did Google the area when I got home and turns out it was once the shopping mecca of Dayton, home to a place called the Salem Mall. Built in 1966 it was the first indoor shopping center in Dayton and survived and thrived into the 1990s before beginning a slow slide to oblivion today.
It’s just weird, sort of ghostly feeling, to visit places that were once obviously thriving and are now shells of their former selves.
I remember in the early days of doing the Amish Cook column I’d visit the south side of Fort Wayne, Indiana a fair amount and I’d see the Southland Mall. As early as the early 1990s it had become a ghostly shell of its former self. At least today there is a Menard’s and, ugh, Wal-Mart there so no real trace of the original mall remains. There's just something sad about seeing a place that was once teeming with life: Christmas shoppers buying presents, teenagers carousing in the food court, and piped in mall music sitting empty.
So, I guess shopping patterns change, demographics change, recessions hit, all of these things, I suppose, contributes to the decline of a retail area. Which is why I always sort of wince when a new one opens up. There’s a massive new shopping complex (a "lifestyle center", the trendy outdoor shopping areas that are supposed to create a "town square" type feel) between Cincinnati and Dayton that just opened up called Liberty Center. I’ve not been there yet, but what will happen to the site 50 years from now when demographics and economics have shifted yet again? Will there be a ghostly, empty outdoor shopping spot?
Is anyone who visits here familiar with the Salem Mall in Dayton. If so, can you share with us what you think happened to cause its decline?
Linda from KY
I think I visited the Salem Mall once, so I have no idea what precipitated its decline. It could very well be the changing patterns of shoppers as you have mentioned.
There are still plenty of thriving indoor malls in my neck of woods, such as the Kenwood Town Centre and the Florence Mall (much more my neck of the woods). There used to be the Crestview Hills Mall. It opened when I was in high school in the late 70s. In fact, my school's marching band was at the grand opening. The acoustics in there were something else. Our music echoed back to us from the many empty hallways. It never really caught on, and finally bit the dust in the early 2000s. They tore it down and replaced it as an outdoor shopping center, the Crestview Hills Town Centre. There are many more stores there and a whole lot more shoppers than when the indoor mall was on the site.
Linda from KY
I forgot to mention how cute your little girl is. I can't believe how big she's getting! I'm glad you two enjoyed your father-daughter day. 🙂
Thanks, Linda...I was just at Kenwood the other week....wow, that place is definitely the "rich mall".....we were just there to return an item to Macy's...sheesh, you have to have some $$ to shop there!
Does anyone remember when Kenwood had a "Kenwood Mall"?
I do think on-line shopping has taken over for so many who find so little time to shop.