Welcome to the Amish365 Marketplace!
Sometimes Amish products and recipes can be difficult to find and even when you can find them, it can be tough to discern what is authentic, what is “faux Amish”. And what is something you should skip. The Amish365 Marketplace takes the guesswork out. We’ve vetted the products sold here. For instance, if you see “clear-jel” mentioned in an Amish365 recipe (a popular thickener used in Amish pies), you’ll be able to buy it confidently here. Ditto for quilts, Amish-made furniture, and other Plain treasures we carefully curate.
One housekeeping note, you are NOT purchasing products from Amish365.com, these are affiliate links to trusted vendors, so once you click the link you leave the site and you’re on your own (well, that sounds a little harsh, but just saying we’re not involved in any of the sales, we’re just connecting you!)
Amish Food Products
These are some classic Amish Food Products that many of our recipes call for! Here are some of our favorite Amish packaged or Amish made.
Amish Baking Must Haves
Regulars of Amish365.com know that there are plenty of Amish recipes (especially pies) that call for thickening agents!
-
Amish Clear-Jel$15.00 -
Amish Perma Flo Thickening Starch$20.99
Amish Pantry Staples
Amish Homemade Delivery Pies
What could be better than getting a delicious Amish Delivery Pie dropped off at your doorstep... thats right, nothing! We don't judge, order them all and have an Amish Pie tasting.
-
Amish Old Fashioned Raisin Pie$44.00
-
Amish Wet Bottom Shoe Fly Pie$15.00
Amish Cookbooks
We find that the best Amish cookbooks aren’t the mass-produced and printed ones (although there are some good ones). The ones with the best culturally relevant recipes are the Mom & Pop small-press books that capture the tastes and traditions in the off the beaten path Amish settlements.
Check out our ever-changing library of Amish cookbooks
