Jump to:
Quick Answer: Der Dutchman serves decent comfort food in an Amish-themed setting, but it's not authentic Amish cuisine. Think of it as "Amish-inspired" rather than genuinely traditional. For families and large groups, it's excellent. For authentic Amish dining, you'll need to look elsewhere.
⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ Overall Rating: ⅘ stars
- Food Quality: ⅘ (Good comfort food, not authentic)
- Value: ⅘ (Generous portions, reasonable prices)
- Atmosphere: ⅘ (Family-friendly, spacious)
- Authenticity: ⅖ (Amish-themed, not Amish-authentic)
Der Dutchman restaurants fall under the umbrella of the Walnut Creek, Ohio-based Dutch Hospitality Group. The company has grown from a single restaurant in Walnut Creek to a 7-restaurant hospitality enterprise with a theater and food distribution arm. The company was founded by families rooted in the Amish and Mennonite culture. Per their website:
"Dutchman Hospitality Group now includes seven restaurants, four inns, seven bakeries, shops, a 500 seat theater and two wholesale food suppliers."
I have been to their restaurants in Shipshewana, Plain City, Berlin, Walnut Creek, and Pinecraft, Florida. They used to have a location in Waynesville, Ohio, but it was destroyed by a fire 20 years ago. Too bad, because I miss that location.
📋 The Truth About Der Dutchman's Authenticity
The Short Answer: Der Dutchman is about as authentic as Olive Garden is to Italian cuisine. It's comfort food with Amish themes, not traditional Amish cooking.
First of all, I like Der Dutchman. I have been to four out of their seven restaurants. And there is an air of authenticity about them. I ran into Amish novelist Wanda Brunstetter once at the Farmstead's buffet. And I know of some Amish women who have worked in Der Dutchman's kitchens, which definitely makes the food more connected to Amish culture when it is made with Amish hands.
Each restaurant is also outfitted with a huge bakery where you can get fat cinnamon rolls, cookies, breads, and spreads to go.
Why Der Dutchman Isn't Truly Authentic
Here's the thing with Der Dutchman: anytime a restaurant tries to please the masses and starts expanded then it seems like the food has to get slightly more bland to appeal to palates. This isn't a huge problem since Amish food is, by its nature, not the most exciting on the palate. This mass production/lose flavor proposition is even more pronounced in Tex-Mex and Asian chains.
What Makes It Less Authentic:
- Mass-produced rather than home-cooked style
- Standardized recipes across all locations
- Buffet format (not traditional Amish serving style)
- Tourist-friendly atmosphere over intimate family dining
- Commercial kitchen operations vs. traditional home cooking methods
What Does Feel Authentic:
- Some Amish employees in the kitchens
- Traditional Amish dishes on the menu
- Generous portions typical of Amish hospitality
- Fresh-baked goods and homemade-style desserts
- Family-friendly atmosphere that reflects Amish values
🗺️ Complete Guide to Der Dutchman Locations
You can get the Der Dutchman experience in the following locations:
All Current Der Dutchman Locations:
Ohio Locations:
- Berlin, Ohio (Farmstead Restaurant) - Often considered the flagship location
- Bellville, Ohio - Smaller location with full menu
- Plain City, Ohio - Features outdoor "mini farm" with goats for kids (my kids LOVE this!)
- Walnut Creek, Ohio - Original location and company headquarters
- Sugarcreek, Ohio - Located in "Little Switzerland of Ohio"
Indiana Location:
- Middlebury, Indiana - Serves northern Indiana Amish country
Florida Location:
- Pinecraft, Florida - Serves the Amish snowbird community
Plus: They have a rolling doughnut truck that travels to various events and locations.
Which Location Should You Visit?
Best for Families: Plain City, Ohio (has the mini farm with goats) Most Authentic Feel: Berlin, Ohio (Farmstead Restaurant) Most Convenient: Depends on your location in Amish country
💸 What to Expect: Menu, Prices, and Experience
The Famous Der Dutchman Buffet
Der Dutchman restaurants are known for their buffet. These are scenes from a visit of mine to Plain City, Ohio. You can go up and load your plate as often as you want and, of course, I did just that.
Main Course Buffet Includes:
- Fried chicken (consistently excellent across locations)
- Roast beef and ham
- Buttered noodles and mashed potatoes
- Green beans, corn, and seasonal vegetables
- Pot roast-style beef
- Various casseroles and side dishes
Separate Salad Bar Features:
- Fresh salads and vegetables
- Fruit selections
- Cottage cheese and various salads
- Soup options (varies by location)
Noodles, mashed potatoes, and meats are all found on the main course buffet. And the food is all really good, authentic Amish, though? I'd call it comfort food fare.
The salad is a whole separate buffet. Buffets in general make me squeamish, so I generally skipped this one.
Signature Items You Must Try
The Famous Dinner Rolls: Each table comes with softball-sized fat, puffy dinner rolls. Along with bottles of "Amish church spread" to squirt on them. That's a nice authentic Amish touch, although the church spread here isn't as good as homemade.
Best Menu Items (Based on Multiple Visits):
- Fried Chicken - Consistently the best item across all locations
- Fresh Dinner Rolls - Huge, fluffy, and warm
- Buttered Noodles - Simple but satisfying
- Ham - Pretty good quality and generous portions
- Bakery Items - Cinnamon rolls, pies, and cookies to-go
And, well, you can see by my plates that I'm not complaining about the food. I make a couple of trips to the main course buffet. I think the fried chicken was my favorite.
But the ham was pretty good too!
There were also veggies like green beans, corn, and a pot roast-type beef. All were good and had me going back to the buffet for more.
Pricing Information
Typical Buffet Prices (as of 2024):
- Adult Dinner Buffet: $16-20
- Adult Lunch Buffet: $14-18
- Children's Buffet: $8-12 (varies by age)
- Senior Discounts: Often available
- Menu items: $12-25 for entrees
Value Assessment: The portions are generous and the buffet allows unlimited trips, making it a good value for families and hearty eaters (like me!).
👪 Der Dutchman: Perfect for Families and Large Groups
Der Dutchman, in my opinion, works best as a place to gather. For instance, we had not had our Christmas gift exchange with some family members yet, even though the holiday was months ago. Der Dutchman was a great halfway point between where those family lived and we live, so after eating we sat at one of many gathering spots in the lobby area and exchange gifts.
My daughters opening their presents.
Why It's Great for Groups:
Family-Friendly Features:
- Spacious seating for large groups
- Kid-friendly menu and atmosphere
- Entertainment for children (like the goats in Plain City)
- Patient staff accustomed to families
- Reasonable prices for feeding large groups
Gathering Spaces:
- Large lobby areas with comfortable seating
- Private dining rooms available for events
- Gift shops for browsing after meals
- Bakery counters for take-home treats
🥄 Where to Find REAL Authentic Amish Food
If you're seeking truly authentic Amish dining experiences, here are better alternatives:
Most Authentic Amish Restaurants:
Ohio:
- Amish Door Restaurant (Wilmot) - Family-owned, traditional recipes
- Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant (Berlin) - Local Amish families' recipes
- Homestead Restaurant (Charm) - Small-town authentic atmosphere
- And my all time favorite, Mrs. Yoder's in Mount Hope, Ohio!
Pennsylvania:
- Shady Maple Smorgasbord (East Earl) - Massive authentic buffet
- Plain & Fancy Farm Restaurant (Bird-in-Hand) - Traditional family-style service
- Katie's Kitchen (Ronks) - Small, family-run establishment
Indiana:
- Das Dutchman Essenhaus (Middlebury) - Different from Der Dutchman, more authentic
- Blue Gate Restaurant (Shipshewana) - Local Amish families' recipes
What Makes These More Authentic:
- Family-style service (not buffet)
- Recipes passed down through generations
- Local Amish family ownership
- Seasonal menus based on local ingredients
- More intimate, less commercialized atmosphere
Practical Information for Your Visit
Hours and Reservations
Typical Hours:
- Monday-Thursday: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- Friday-Saturday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Important Notes:
- Hours vary by location and season
- Some locations close on Sundays
- Call ahead for large groups
- No reservations needed for regular seating
- Private dining rooms require advance booking
What to Bring/Expect
Dress Code: Casual, family-friendly Wait Times: Can be long during peak tourist seasons Parking: Ample parking at all locations Accessibility: All locations are wheelchair accessible Payment: Cash and all major credit cards accepted
Tips for the Best Experience
- Arrive Early: Beat the crowds, especially on weekends
- Bring Cash: Some locations offer cash discounts
- Save Room for Dessert: The bakery items are worth it
- Plan Extra Time: These are destinations, not quick stops
- Bring the Kids: They'll love the family atmosphere
The Final Verdict: Is Der Dutchman Worth It?
So, again, my Der Dutchman verdict: a great place to gather, to fill your belly, to buy some baked goods, I have zero complaints about the place. I like it. I just wouldn't call it authentic Amish and I'm not sure that Der Dutchman would call it that either. It's comfort food and comfort space.
When to Choose Der Dutchman:
✅ Choose Der Dutchman if you want:
- Family-friendly dining with large groups
- Consistent, reliable comfort food
- Convenient locations in Amish country
- Buffet-style dining with variety
- Shopping and entertainment in one location
- Reasonable prices for generous portions
❌ Skip Der Dutchman if you're seeking:
- Intimate, authentic Amish dining
- Traditional family-style service
- Recipes unchanged for generations
- Quiet, non-commercialized atmosphere
- Gourmet or sophisticated cuisine
Our Recommendation:
For First-Time Visitors to Amish Country: Der Dutchman is a good introduction that won't disappoint, especially if you have children.
For Authentic Amish Food Seekers: Visit one of the smaller, family-owned restaurants listed above for a more genuine experience.
For Large Groups and Families: Der Dutchman is hard to beat for convenience, space, and kid-friendly atmosphere.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Der Dutchman actually owned by Amish people? A: The company was founded by families with Amish and Mennonite roots, but it's now a commercial enterprise rather than a traditional Amish business.
Q: Can I make reservations? A: Regular seating is first-come, first-served. Private dining rooms can be reserved for large groups.
Q: Do they have non-buffet options? A: Yes, most locations offer both buffet and à la carte menu options.
Q: Are the portions large? A: Yes, very generous portions that reflect Amish hospitality traditions.
Q: Is it worth the drive? A: If you're already in Amish country, absolutely. Don't make it your only destination, but it's a solid choice for a satisfying meal.
Conclusion: A Solid Choice with Realistic Expectations
Der Dutchman restaurants occupy a unique niche in Amish country tourism. They're not authentic Amish dining in the traditional sense, but they offer reliable, hearty comfort food in a family-friendly atmosphere that captures some of the warmth and hospitality associated with Amish culture.
Think of Der Dutchman as the "Cracker Barrel of Amish country" – it's themed, commercial, and designed for tourists, but it does what it does well. The food is good, the portions are generous, the staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is welcoming for families and large groups.
If you're touring Amish country with kids, need to feed a large group, or want a convenient, reliable meal, Der Dutchman is an excellent choice. Just don't expect an intimate, authentic Amish dining experience – and that's perfectly fine.
For visitors who want the full spectrum of Amish country dining, consider Der Dutchman for one meal and seek out smaller, family-owned restaurants for comparison. You'll appreciate both experiences for different reasons.
Bottom Line: Der Dutchman delivers on comfort food and family-friendly dining. It's Amish-inspired rather than Amish-authentic, but sometimes that's exactly what you need.
Leave a Reply