Grabill, Indiana: A Guide to One of America's Most Unique Amish Communities

Grabill sits in Allen County, just 18 miles northeast of Fort Wayne, and it has been quietly one of the most fascinating Amish communities in America for a very long time. I just didn't know it until I visited.

A Settlement Unlike Any Other

Most American Amish trace their roots to Pennsylvania Dutch country — Swiss and German families who arrived in Pennsylvania in the 1700s and spread westward from there. Grabill's Amish follow a different path entirely.

The Grabill-New Haven Amish community in Allen County was founded in 1853 by families who migrated from Stark County, Ohio — and this is the only Indiana settlement made up primarily of 19th-century Amish immigrants from Alsace-Lorraine, France. That French-German border region origin gives this community subtly different customs, surnames, and traditions than most Amish settlements you'll encounter elsewhere.

The family names here tell the story. The Grabill settlement is the only one in North America where you'll run into the surname Lengacher in such large numbers. Schmucker and Graber are also dominant surnames — names that reflect the specific families who founded this community nearly 170 years ago.

Today the Allen County settlement numbers approximately 800 households, about 3,500 adults and children, in 19 church districts. That makes it a substantial community — large enough to be vibrant and self-sustaining, small enough to retain the intimate feel that the bigger tourist settlements have largely lost.

What Makes Grabill Different

Grabill is genuinely unlike most Amish communities I've visited, and I've visited a lot of them.

The Amish here are more permissive when it comes to allowing technology into their business lives — more so than many other settlements. You'll notice it in small ways that add up to a distinct character. The community feels entrepreneurial and forward-leaning while still maintaining the essential markers of Old Order life: horse and buggy, plain dress, worship in homes.

Many Amish men here work in construction, contracting, or carpentry rather than running home-based businesses or farming. That's different from, say, Hardin County, Ohio, where you'll find dozens and dozens of home-based businesses from toy shops to bakeries. In Grabill, the economy runs differently — more integrated with the broader Fort Wayne economy, less oriented toward farm-based cottage industries.

That said, there are still plenty of fresh egg signs at the end of driveways, and I came away with way too many eggs on my visit. Some things are universal across Amish settlements.

The other thing that strikes you immediately about Grabill is its setting. Located in northeast Allen County, Grabill offers a glimpse of an authentic living Amish community filled with fascinating shops, rural scenes, picturesque farms and horse-drawn vehicles Visit Fort Wayne — all within an easy drive of a major city. That combination of accessibility and authenticity is rarer than you'd think.

What to See and Do in Grabill

Grabill Country Sales

The don't-miss destination in Grabill. This is a huge bulk food store and buffet owned by Elmer Lengacher — an entrepreneurial Amishman who also owns the local Save-A-Lot grocery store, which tells you something about how this community operates.

You'll find Amish-made fruit jams and spreads, pickled items, pasta, cooking supplies, and spices, along with a huge selection of repackaged items — nuts, dried fruit, and candy purchased in bulk and repackaged, which means real savings for shoppers. The buffet and deli are excellent. Don't leave without trying the homemade ice cream — giant tubs of blackberry with nuts, banana, fudge, and strawberry waiting in the freezer section.

Grabill Country Sales even has a website, which itself tells you something about this community's relationship with technology compared to more conservative settlements.

H. Souder & Sons General Store

One of the few genuine working general stores left in Indiana. This is the real thing — not a tourist recreation of a general store but an actual functioning one that has served this community for generations. Worth every minute you spend inside.

The Country Shops of Grabill

The antique and flea market in Grabill is remarkable — large, well-stocked, and genuinely worth the detour. Next to it sits H. Souder & Sons, which means you can make an afternoon of this corner of town without running out of things to discover.

Amish Farm Stores

Many Amish stores in Grabill are located on the farms themselves, which means a visit here gives you something increasingly rare — a chance to see how the Amish actually live while you shop. Follow the handmade signs. Stop when something looks interesting. That's the Grabill way.

Nolt Family Dinner Haus

12530 Cuba Road, Grabill, IN 46741 | (260) 627-xxxx

A local institution worth knowing about for a sit-down meal in the heart of Amish country.

A Note for Visitors

Grabill is an honest Amish community, not a themed tourist destination. The Amish here don't exist to be tourist attractions — they are real people living in a real community that happens to be one of the oldest and most historically distinctive in America. That means the experience here is more authentic than many of the better-known Amish tourist destinations, but it also means you won't find the density of visitor-oriented businesses you'd encounter in Berlin, Ohio or Shipshewana, Indiana.

Come with curiosity and patience. Drive the back roads. Follow the signs. Buy the eggs. Stop at the general store. That's the right way to do Grabill.

---

Getting There

Grabill sits about 18 miles northeast of downtown Fort Wayne on State Road 37. It's easily combined with a visit to the nearby Adams County Swiss Amish settlement around Berne — another distinctive community with its own unique character — for a full day of Amish country exploration in northeastern Indiana.

The Amish Homes of Grabill

I visited the Amish settlement of Grabill, Indiana and one of the most striking characteristics of the community are the homes.  There are an eclectic mix of suburban type homes to traditional rambling Amish farmhomes.  As you can see from some of the photos below, many of the Amish homes in Grabill look like ones you'd see in "Suburban Anywhere."  While the traditional farmhouses that are there are often added on to and sprawling to accommodate multi-generational families.

Note the solar panels visible on rooftops, the Amish of Grabill have definitely embraced solar which powers all sorts of things without putting them "on the grid."

Ice Machine

The Amish in Grabill, Indiana share a lot of close family and tradition ties with the Amish of Berne, Indiana but they part ways in other areas.  Use of technology is one, or at least how it is seen publicly.   Here is an "ice machine" that I saw out along rural Cuba Road in Grabill.  Inside this ice machine is what you'd find at any convenience store: bags of ice.  You can just leave your money in the cooler or walk over to the nearest farmhouse and pay.

"It's most just Amish that use it but occasionally we'll have someone who is having a party or gathering that needs ice and they'll use it also," said a teenage girl who was at the nearest house.  At first I drove by the machine a couple of times but then I thought to myself that I have to stop and ask the details.  The parents, unfortunately, were not home. But the girl says the family has been in the ice business for a long time.  Most Amish homes, even with plentiful solar power, probably don't have freezers at home, so being able to buy a bag of ice just a quick buggy jaunt away is probably quite convenient!