As editor of Amish365, I have spent almost three decades exploring Amish communities from coast to coast. I’ve sampled enough cinnamon rolls, fried pies, and donuts to know a good Amish or Mennonite bakery when I see one! Our absolute favorites are the Amish bakeries tucked away in an outbuilding or basement in an actual Amish home. That’s where you’ll find the most cultural authenticity, so we tried to keep this list focused on the less touristy, off-the-beaten path places.
This list is our attempt to pull all the bakeries together into one easy spot.. I always remind people, though, when it comes to Amish bakeries: beware. Many of them open and close without much notice. We tried to vouch for accuracy as much as possible with this list, but this list will evolve and change, and we’re counting on you to help keep it current and add bakeries that we might’ve missed.
This list is in no way meant to be comprehensive and complete, there are many great Amish and Mennonite bakeries out there that I’m sure are not on this list. But if you know of one, please give us the information here email us details at [email protected]
Browse Amish Bakeries By Location
Monte Vista, CO - Worth The Drive Bakery is known for their breads, rolls, pastries,...
Dover, DE - This is a classic Amish country store featuring wood stoves, groceries, bakery...
Sarasota, FL - Old-fashioned locale known for hearty American & Amish cuisine, including homemade pies....
Montezuma, GA - A Mennonite-owned bakery and old-fashioned cafeteria. Meatloaf and homemade pies are popular...
E. Arthur, IL - Hours: 7:30 a.m. – 5:30 p.m. Monday – Saturday (closes at 4:30...
Hours: 8 a.m. – 5 pm., Monday – Saturday Reviewers report Best place for a...
Flat Rock, IL - Hours: 9:30 a.m – 4:30 p.m., closed Wednesday and Sundays Amazing...
Dexter, KY - Hours, Wednesday only 8 a.m. – 5 p.m. Very friendly people with...
Guthrie, KY - Hours: 8 am. – 5 p.m., Monday – Saturday Jam cakes are...
Browse All Amish Bakeries
Monte Vista, CO - Worth The Drive Bakery is known for their breads, rolls, pastries,...
Dover, DE - This is a classic Amish country store featuring wood stoves, groceries, bakery...
Sarasota, FL - Old-fashioned locale known for hearty American & Amish cuisine, including homemade pies....
Montezuma, GA - A Mennonite-owned bakery and old-fashioned cafeteria. Meatloaf and homemade pies are popular...
Oblong, IL - Hours: varies Comments: Reviews report high quality baked goods here! Back to...
E. Arthur, IL - Hours: 7:30 a.m. – 5:30 p.m. Monday – Saturday (closes at 4:30...
Hours: 8 a.m. – 5 pm., Monday – Saturday Reviewers report Best place for a...
Flat Rock, IL - Hours: 9:30 a.m – 4:30 p.m., closed Wednesday and Sundays Amazing...
Dexter, KY - Hours, Wednesday only 8 a.m. – 5 p.m. Very friendly people with...
Guthrie, KY - Hours: 8 am. – 5 p.m., Monday – Saturday Jam cakes are...
Explore Our Top Recipes of Amish Bakery Favorites
- Amish Peanut Butter Easter Eggs
- Homemade Amish Butterscotch Cream Pie
- The Amish Cook: Amazing Eclair Cake
- The Amish Cook: Blonde Brownies
- The Amish Cook: Brown Sugar Bars
- Sour Milk Cookies and 4 other Amish Recipes Using Sour Milk
- The Amish Cook: Russian Creme Dessert
- Old-Fashioned Amish Fastnachts (The Recipe and History!)
