Heath Candy Bar Cookies

Jump to Recipe

Reader Penny shared this recipe for Health Candy Bar cookies, a festive holiday cookie. Which got me to think about Heath bars. Out of all the candy bars I could eat, Heath would be down the list. But Heath bar pieces seem to have really gained in popularity at those yogurt mix-in places or marble slab ice cream parlors. Heath, with its almond, milk chocolate, and toffee blend makes for a good mix-in or, in this case, cookie add-in. But why not a Kit Kat Cookie? Or a Nestle Crunch Cookie? Or, come to think of it, a "Krackel Cookie." Krackel bars, in my humble opinion, are very underrated. Snickers are overrated. The lowly Krackel bar tastes a lot like a Nestle Crunch bar, but for some reason I like it better. Both bars are milk chocolate with crisped rice, but the Krackel seems thicker and ricier.

I'm not an Almond Joy fan at all, why stick a big nut right in the middle of a perfectly good candy bar? But Mounds bars I have a developed a late in life affinity for....Man, I wonder if one could make a Mounds Bar cookie? You'd have to like coconut.

And, by the way, would you find these candy bar cookies in an Amish kitchen? Perhaps. Candies are a popular way to celebrate the holiday season and if an Amish baker has some bars sitting around I imagine it doesn't take long for them to end up in batter.

A couple of other notes about this recipe. Walnuts are optional, I'd probably leave them out. I just don't understand why people dump nuts into everything. Ruins most things, I think (although I am grudgingly coming around that they do add some nice crunch to some things)

This recipe also calls for Heath bits, which you can buy in the grocery in the baking aisle, but I'd be tempted to buy a bunch of Crunch bars, crush them and use this recipe to make Crunch or Krackel cookies. Feel free to experiment!

So, without further delay, let's look at this Heath Candy Bar Cookie recipe:

Jump to:

• 🍪Heath Candy Bar Cookie Ingredients
• 📋Cookie Instructions
• 🍫More Amish Candy Bar Creations
• 🖨️Printer-Friendly Heath Candy Bar Cookie Recipe

🍪Heath Candy Bar Cookie Ingredients

• 1/3 cup soft shortening
• 1/3 cup butter
• ½ cup white sugar'
• ½ cup brown sugar ( packed )
• 1 egg
• 1 teaspoon vanilla
• 1 ½ cups flour
• ½ tsp baking soda
• ½ tsp salt
• ½ cup chopped walnuts ( optional)
• 1 cup Heath chips

📋Cookie Instructions

1. Mix shortening, butter and both sugars until well blended.
2. Add egg and vanilla then add the rest of the ingredients, mixing well.
3. Drop dough by rounded teaspoon on cookie sheet.
4. Bake at 350 degrees for 10 minutes or until lightly brown but still soft.

🍫More Amish Candy Bar Creations

As I said, candybars are not a stranger in Amish kitchens. Let's go through the Amish365 archives to see what other candy creations we can find!

Kit Kat Brownies

Okay, these would be high, high up on my list. Kit Kats equal bliss....

Homemade Baby Ruth Bars

These are better than the store-bought kind!

Homemade Twix Bars

Twix bars are amazing, underrated...so much better than a plain ol' milk chocolate bar.

Reese's Stuffed Peanut Butter Bars

This recipe is Heaven, best of the best because Reese's are the best!

🖨️Printer-Friendly Heath Candy Bar Cookie Recipe