The Amish Cook's Classic Taco Soup

Jump to Recipe

If I were to ask you for a show of hands of who likes venison, I’m curious what response we’d be looking at?

When Michael, from Clarks Summit Pa, inquired about venison recipes, it got the wheels in my head turning.  

Jump to:

• 📸 Editor's Notes and Photos
• 🥣 Classic Taco Soup
• 📋 Instructions
• 🥣 More Amish Soup Recipes
• 🖨️ Full Recipe

You know, when I was a very young girl, and we lived in the famous Amish country of Holmes County, Ohio, we seldom if ever had venison since deer were much more scarce in those heavily populated areas.  

Upon moving to Flat Rock, we were blessed with lots of wildlife all over our 90-acre farm. There were so many deer in the area that they would develop serious diseases unless they were thinned out.

Thanks to my Dad, who would go hunting for his family, year after year. Though some years were more challenging to bag deer, he kept doing all in his power to feed his family this natural meat. Though we felt blessed with all the venison we could get from year to year, it was an adjustment to switch from beef to deer meat.

Some didn’t mind the game-y flavor; others declared it to be less than tasty. We soon learned that by trimming out as much fat as possible and using only doe meat for a burger, you could get by with a very minimal game-y flavor.   with some taco seasoning and chili powder, hiding any game-effect it may still have had.  

We also have many special memories of times spent with Dad in the woods or the family butcherings where my uncles and their families joined us after deer hunting season. We’d give it all we had as we spent the entire evening butchering over tea, snacks, and juicy conversations.

There is one evening I will never think about without having a smile cross my face and heart, for that matter. There was a circle of us around the large table. Our knives kept busy as we chit-chatted. Then turning to Uncle Paul, who was my employer for a number of years when I worked in their store and had come to be a favorite uncle, I asked, “What would you say if I would have a date on Sunday?” His expression was priceless; it said, “You've got to be making up some crazy stories!”  (Since courtship or dating is only for those seriously considering marriage, the first date is a big deal and is 'talk of the town'.)

Turning toward the others, he probed, “Is she serious? Come on, is she serious?”  Now Paul is always the type to figure out surprises or events, but for once he didn't know a thing about it.

Then triumphantly, I asked, “What do you think about Ephraim Yoder’s son, Daniel?” Without even an answer back, I knew he'd be impressed- who didn’t have respect for this amazing young man? You’re probably like, “Oh come on, there's more good guys out there besides him.” Okay, I agree, but to me, Daniel was a one and only, and today, 13 years later, he still is!   

And now Daniel is the one to provide us with venison for our growing family. I wonder how life can bring so many changes, so slowly but inexpressibly fast. Yes, countless are the good times the children have of going with Daddy in the woods, sharing a snack, and having conversations on their one-on-one time with Daddy.

Besides that, this winter, we tried something new for our family. We butchered one of our grass-fed beef, and it has added a tasty dimension to put on the table, not to mention the health benefits of eating real meat that has been raised in actual natural living conditions.  

Now back to Michael, from Pa. Thanks for your inquiry. Yes, we use any recipes asking for beef interchangeably with venison.  

I’ll leave you with a beef/ venison recipe my mother introduced us to when I was down with the flu a couple of weeks ago. It’s perfect for these cooler winter evenings. Those are the times I’m incredibly grateful for hundreds of pounds of meat in the freezer to feed my little ones at any given time. Why yesterday afternoon, when I was making casseroles, Julia came along and wondered if she could have some browned deer burger. “Why sure!” I responded. Soon she had a bowl of venison topped with her favorite homemade sweet ‘n sour dressing and a spoonful pizza sauce. She declared it to be one of the best snacks. 

And you should see little Joshua. At 1 ½, it looks like he’s taking after his daddy in being a meat-eater. He doesn’t eat all that many solid foods, but he’ll take a burger any day.

📸 Editor's Notes and Photos

This Classic Taco Soup is delicious and full of flavor and it comes with its own "built in heat thermometer." And what I mean by that is that the ingredient list includes "salsa." It doesn't say what kind of salsa, so you could use mild (which is what we used since my father thinks anything that has a whiff of heat is too spicy, I tell him that he thinks Vanilla Wafers are too spicy), or you could add some heat by using medium or hot salsa! Whichever you choose, you'll love the soup.

Salsa, by the way, is something that has become super popular among the Amish over the past decades. Peppers, tomatoes, and the like make salsa a natural fit among the Amish.

Use two cups of tomato juice go into this Classic Taco Soup. Ugh, my Dad used to drink that Clamato juice. No thanks, stick with tomato juice. Although, I bet you could experiment and use V-8 vegetable juice and get good results.

I was amazed and how good this Classic Taco Soup tasted after just simmering for 15 minutes on medium heat. I'd let it simmer even longer just to let the flavors meld. And, really, the soup tastes even better the next day after the flavors have really melded.

🥣 Classic Taco Soup

• ¾ pound hamburger
• ½ c chopped onions
• 2 Tbsp. flour
• 2 cups tomato juice
• 1 cup chicken broth
• 1 small can black or pinto beans
• 1 cup salsa
• 1 Tbsp, honey
• ¾ teas. cumin
• 1 ½ teas. chili powder
• ½ teaspoon garlic powder
• salt and black pepper to taste

📋 Instructions

1. Fry hamburger until no longer pink, drain. (Add onions last several minutes of frying to saute lightly.)
2. Sprinkle with flour and stir well.
3. Now add tomato juice and broth, stirring to heat.
4. Add rest of ingredients and heat to boiling.
5. Stir frequently.
6. Simmer for 15 minutes.
7. Serve with corn chips and a dollop of Ranch Dressing.

🥣 More Amish Soup Recipes

Winter's Day Soup

Bupli

Amish Turkey Soup

One-Kettle Soup

🖨️ Full Recipe