In an age where viral sensations come and go with the scroll of a screen, one young Amish couple has captured hearts and minds across the world with their authentic country music performances. Ben and Rose, a married couple from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, have become an unlikely internet phenomenon, bringing their beautiful harmonies and traditional Amish values to millions of viewers through their YouTube channel. So far, I've not been able to find a last name for them, but that doesn't really matter, they are just amazing to listen to!
My girls and I now love singing along to Ben & Rose. They are upbeat and or relatable songs without being too relatable (in other words, I've read some song lyrics by some Amish over the years and they'll deal with graphic topics like cancer or sickness or death an the lyrics will be so gloomy that the song gets lost....but I think this is an outlet of expression in a culture that typically doesn't promote that).
From Humble Beginnings to Viral Fame
Ben and Rose are members of the Old Order Amish church—"the horse-and-buggy of the Amish faith" whose "strict codes generally forbid them from things like the internet." Yet their musical journey began in the most traditional way possible. Rose had previously performed at the Corner Coffee Shop in downtown Intercourse, across from Kitchen Kettle, where she played with her sister as a duet for weekend audiences filled with both Amish and English patrons.
The turning point came when the couple decided to reach out to Conrad Fisher, a singer/songwriter with Mennonite roots who operates Ragamuffin Hall in McCoysville, Pennsylvania. Fisher's studio is housed in an old church built in 1871 where he holds performances and operates a recording studio. The singing couple had their brother drive them to Ragamuffin Hall, and Conrad produced "Slowly But Surely" for them like he would any other country song.
Their breakthrough came with their cover of the classic country song "Slowly But Surely," previously recorded by artists like Merle Haggard and Bonnie Owens. When they were done recording, Conrad Fisher convinced the two to make a quick video for the song, if only for themselves. But at some point, Ben & Rose decided to upload the video on YouTube, and it's since found strong reception.
Musical Style and Comparisons
The couple's sound has drawn widespread praise and notable comparisons to country music legends. Producer Conrad Fisher told Savingcountrymusic.com that "She sounds like Dolly," referring to Rose's vocal resemblance to Dolly Parton. This comparison has been echoed by countless fans who have discovered their music online.
Their repertoire spans both country and gospel genres, with covers of classics like "The Little Mountain Church House," "Circle of Love," "But for the Blood," and "Here Today." Each performance showcases their natural harmony and authentic delivery that feels both timeless and fresh.
Growing Success and Recognition
Since launching their YouTube channel, Ben and Rose have achieved remarkable success. Their half-dozen songs on their channel are approaching 4 million views already. Their first song "Slowly But Surely" has been viewed over 1.2 million times on YouTube.
The couple's musical evolution is evident in their latest releases. While Rose typically takes the lead vocals, Ben has the more prominent singing voice in songs like "The Little Mountain Church House," with Rose lower in the mix as more of a supporting vocal. Their instrumentation has also expanded, with Ben switching between guitar and mandolin depending on the song.
Community Response and Cultural Considerations
The phenomenon of an Old Order Amish couple sharing music on the internet has naturally raised questions about community acceptance and potential backlash. However, the reality appears more nuanced than some might expect.
According to Conrad Fisher, who works closely with the couple, "Ben and Rose are indeed with the old order Amish church, not in rumspringa. There are some Amish communities where this might get you excommunicated, but the Amish Churches in PA are in such an upheaval about other things right now, they'll probably get away with it without even being reprimanded by the church."
The acceptance within their own community appears positive. One commenter shared: "I came across ben and Rose while watching another youtube video. I was so impressed with their singing, I played the video for an Amish friend of mine from Curryville, MO. Before long, her daughter, 3 other Amish ladies, and 2 'English' patrons were enjoying it."
However, not all responses have been universally supportive. Some community members and observers have questioned whether their musical activities align with traditional Amish values. One commenter noted, "I know a lot of Amish who appreciate music and would love to play more than a mouth organ but are not permitted to play a stringed instrument or be recorded. These two must be on their way out of the church."
Theological and Cultural Balance
The couple appears to navigate the tension between their musical calling and their faith traditions carefully. According to AmishRules.com, Amish can play and listen to live music, "but it has to be music that is uplifting, and culturally appropriate." Their choice of songs—from classic country to gospel—reflects this principle.
Their latest releases include gospel songs like "But for the Blood" and "Here Today," which demonstrate their commitment to faith-centered themes. These selections show how they balance their musical gifts with their spiritual values, choosing material that is both "uplifting and culturally appropriate."
Looking Forward
As Ben and Rose continue to release new music, they represent something unique in both the Amish and country music worlds. As Conrad Fisher observes, "Very seldom can anyone be a part of something that is truly 'new under the sun' but I think an Old Order Amish couple recording a country song and putting a video out on YouTube qualifies."
Their success challenges assumptions about Amish engagement with modern technology while demonstrating how authentic artistry can transcend cultural boundaries. Whether they will continue to find acceptance within their community while pursuing their musical gifts remains to be seen, but their impact on both Amish representation and country music is undeniable.
Ben and Rose have shown that sometimes the most powerful music comes from the most unexpected places, carrying with it the authenticity and simplicity that our modern world often craves. As their viewership continues to grow and their music reaches new audiences, they remain a testament to the power of staying true to one's roots while sharing one's gifts with the world.
I will say, though, that this would never have flown 30 years ago when I first started studying Amish culture. There just wouldn't have been room for that in the Amish church then, but I think the Amish have adapted and evolved philosophically since then so that maybe there is room today. Musical instruments have typically not been very well-received among the Amish.
For those interested in following Ben and Rose's musical journey, their songs can be found on their YouTube channel under "Ben & Rose." Their music is produced by Conrad Fisher at Ragamuffin Hall in McCoysville, Pennsylvania.
Leave a Reply