By Kevin Williams
In today's other post I wrote about disappearing local flavors and regional culinary specialties. One such regional specialty is sugar cream pie which seems to enjoy a special affinity in Indiana. I'm not saying you won't find sugar creams elsewhere, but Indiana seems to be its birthplace and it may well have started in the kitchen of an Amish cook. This is an interesting article that surmises the pie may have its roots with the Indiana Amish or Shakers. I have my doubts about the Shaker origins. They are often associated with a similar pie called a "chess pie." Sugar cream pies and others of their ilk are sometimes called "desperation pies" or "Depression pies"....these types of pies were a mainstay during the Great Depression when fruit was scarce and people just wanted to whip up a pie out of whatever they had on hand. The tradition of sugar cream pie endures to this day. Now (maybe I'm just a naive food romantic at heart) I am convinced that in some elderly Amish woman's kitchen in Berne or Daviess County, Indiana (I'm guessing Berne as "ground zero" for the pie) that someone is still making the perfect sugar cream pie: silky smooth sweet and eggless.
One often overlooked possibility is that this pie could well have its roots in the German Baptist Brethren community which has a large presence just south of Berne, Indiana. Cooking and baking styles are similar.
The pie pictured here was one I picked up at a German Baptist Bakery, which I'll write more about in the coming days. It was/is an amazing bakery!
Meanwhile, this is a recipe for classic
Meanwhile below is a recipe for classic Indiana sugar cream pie, and I got this recipe from the Berne community so it may very well be one of the original "Holy Grail" versions. There are small variations in sugar cream recipes, but this is a classic.
- 3 /4 cup sugar
- 1 /4 cup cornstarch
- 1 /2 cup margarine
- 2 1 /4 cup whole milk
- 2 teaspoons vanilla
- cinnamon to taste (1 – 2 teaspoons, more if you like cinnamon!)
- Cook together sugar, milk, and cornstarch.
- When thickened, add margarine and vanilla.
- Pour into a baked pie shell.
- Sprinkle with cinnamon.
This looks so yummy! I grew up in the Hagerstown and Richmond area and we always had sugar cream pies for special occasions. I think my mother made most of those, but a very good bakery pie is from Mrs. Wicks Pie Company in Winchester, IN, just north of Richmond and south of Berne. Have you ever visited? They have Sugar Cream pies along with many other pies and the store has a little lunch area where you can buy sandwiches, slice of pie or other desserts. I also have a recipe that I'll find and send on to you. Thanks for sharing this!
Kathy, I wondered if anyone would mention Wick's! Yes, they probably make the best commercially available version of SCP. I've been there a time or two. I'm headed right for that area next week when I visit Economy, Indiana!
I grew up in Muncie, IN and we always had a Wicks sugar cream pie for special occasions. I've made a few but I think I have "out grown" them. They are too sweet!
I may be wrong but I think that the Wick's Sugar Cream Pie is the state pie of Indiana.