Amish Christmas Plum Pudding

Jump to Recipe

Jump to:

• 🍮 Amish Plum Pudding Ingredients
• 📋 Instructions
• 🍮 More Amish Puddings
• 🖨️ Full Recipe

Who hasn’t watched Christmas Carol and salivated over the scenes with flaming puddings?  There are also songs about “figgy puddings.”   Some definitions of figgy puddings say:  “Figgy Pudding is a vague term used for a class of traditional Christmas dishes usually forming sweet and savory cakes, containing a sour-sweet creamy layer of honey, fruits and nuts.” Here is any interesting history about Christmas pudding, or plum pudding, as many call it.

The article describes the pudding as:

 By the 19th century the ingredients were more or less standardized to suet, brown sugar, raisins and currents, candied orange peel, eggs, breadcrumbs, nutmeg, cloves, allspice and plenty of alcohol.

So, we have a class of puddings with a rich, colorful history.  But what happens to this same pudding makes its way into Amish culture? 

First of all, “plum pudding” isn’t really plum pudding.  At least very rarely.  Plum pudding – like figgy pudding – is sort of a catch-all term for a class of puddings.  Most plum puddings just contain raisins, currents, or prunes, usually dried.  I suppose there’s a recipe out there with plums, but rarely.  I actually was pretty bummed when I learned plum pudding doesn’t contain plums (well, it has prunes, which are dried plums, but still not quite what I was thinking)

Anyway, what happens when a throw-together pudding with a bunch of ingredients gets into an Amish kitchen?  Answer: it gets simplified.  I got this Amish Plum Pudding recipe years ago from an Amish cook in Ohio and it only contains 5 ingredients, far less than the typical dozen or so ingredients you might see.  A typical plum pudding, you can throw in carrots,  pineapple, pears, cinnamon, molasses, and more.   And here’s something funny, this plum pudding actually contains pudding.  That’s something you rarely see. I have seen some Amish recipes from 50 years ago or more than call for suet, but this recipe - the one I am posting - has no savory component.

You can use butterscotch or vanilla.  Not sure chocolate really works well here.  Anyway, this is a funny recipe in terms of the historical bears of plum pudding. This is a simple, scaled-down version.  Definitely delicious and worth making, but not necessarily what one might think of when they think of the Cratchits and plum pudding.

📋 Instructions

1. Prepare pudding as directed on package. Cool.
2. Put prunes in enough water to cover in covered sauce pan.
3. Bring to a boil then remove from heat and cool without removing lid.
4. Crush graham crackers and put ¾ of the crumbs in bottom of large oblong dish.
5. Layer prunes, marshmallows, nuts and pudding on top of graham crumbs.
6. Put remaining crumbs on top.

🍮 More Amish Puddings

Classic Cinnamon Pudding

Homemade Butterscotch Pudding

Amish Raisin Pudding

🖨️ Full Recipe