Every week I drop the most unique and diverse Amish made products featured on Amazon & Etsy. There are many authentic or super products out there that are either Amish-made or Amish-themed and I will hand-pick the best and share them here and you can get them through our affiliate links below (do all your other Amazon shopping while you are there also!)
I do my best to either personally try each item I feature here or carefully vet it. I can't always guarantee an item will be in stock, but I think you'll find this a fascinating collection of Amish-themed goods.
- Week of April 24, 2023
- Week of May 26, 2023
- Week of June 2, 2023
- Week of June 9, 2023:
- Week of June 16, 2023 - Amish Chickweed Salve, Simply Delicious Amish Cooking, and Raisin Pie!
- Week of June 23 - E-Cloths and Amish Peach Butter
- Week of June 30, 2023 - Amish-themed gift basket, Oatmeal Whoopie Pies, and Shoofly Pie Bars
- Week of 7-14-2023 - Cherry Jam, Strawberry Salsa, and Espresso Whoopies
- July 21, 2023: Zucchini Relish, Black Walnut Fudge, and a Painting
- Week of July 28 - Ben's Amish Pretzels/Ben's Amish Cinnamon Rolls
- Week of August 11 - Shipshewana Happy Salt and Amish Sweet Potato Butter, Pumpkin Pecan Butter, and Pumpkin Butter!
- More About Amish Life
Week of April 24, 2023
Brand: Bird-in-Hand Bakeshop
First of all, Bird-Hand-Bakeshop...I have actually been to this place before and love their products. The reality is that many of you will never make it to Lancaster County's Amish country, by getting items from Bird-in-Hand Bakeshop you can bring it to you.
Amish Shoofly Pie: A pack of two of these delicious shoo-fly pies, it's expensive to order, but the pie is rich. And worth every penny! Order here!
Check out this pack of amazing Amish whoopie pies, also from Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop.
Creamy Amish Fudge from Amish Buggy, I have had this product and they are produced in the Amish community of Arthur, Illinois. Good stuff!
Week of May 26, 2023
Brand: Byler's Relish House
I absolutely love anything from Byler's Relish House, an authentic Amish-owned certified cannery. This sweet relish is perfect on sandwiches. One reviewer says: amazing on burgers, as a chip dip and straight from the jar! brings back memories of my childhood and homemade piccadilly relish. can't get enough!
Order Piccalilli for a slightly different relish. Readers recommend this as a perfect hot dog topper, not quite as sweet as sweet pepper relish. Other suggestions are to mix this into a meatloaf before baking, makes it moist and flavorful!
Week of June 2, 2023
This Amish church spread stuff is so, so good. We go through a lot of this at our house. Pro-tip: squeeze bottles of this - like these - are great, but at some point when it gets low, it gets tough to squeeze out, so just unscrew the top lid and use a butter knife to get it out. You won't want to let any go to waste. So good on bread, crackers, etc.
I love this vegetable and bread bin which seems to capture Amish craftsmanship and creativity perfectly. Here's some more about it: AMISH-MADE FURNITURE: Handcrafted in Lancaster, PA, by expert Amish woodworkers, each beautiful bread bin is made of pine wood to resist decay and rot. It also includes wire mesh in the doors. This potato and onion storage container can also be used as a bread box for the kitchen countertop.
Week of June 9, 2023:
Brand: Amish Buggy Brand
I think this stuff is addictive, I prefer it to salt. So good. Here is the description: Table salt alternative, use on bread, meats, pastas, salads, vegetables (corn on the cob), casseroles, etc. Weavers Dutch Country Seasonings is a family owned and opperated business. Our owners were born and raised Amish, and share the culture's love for food and family. Our desire was to bring the two together, by including our children in the business, and of course, by bringing family together through good cooking. What better way, right?
Amish Buggy brand are Amish-made products from Arthur, Illinois. I love anything they make. These homegrown and home-canned peaches get rave reviews!
Week of June 16, 2023 - Amish Chickweed Salve, Simply Delicious Amish Cooking, and Raisin Pie!
I have this book and love it. Sherry Gore, the author, is a convert to the Plain faith and she wrote this book while living in Pinecraft, the Amish winter haven in Florida. So the recipes are Amish but with tropical twists. Things like grapefruit pie and alligator nuggets alongside more typical Amish fare. You can get Simply Delicious here.
I visited their facility outside of Berlin, Ohio in the heart of Amish country where they use generations-old formulations for these creams. They gave me a bunch of free samples and now that I have run out, I need more...Did really well on my dry feet, also if you have any irritated skin, it is a great all-purpose ointment that is soothing! You can order Chickweed Salve from Amazon here.
SIGH, one of my quirks...I am not a huge raisin fan, but I LOVE raisin pie. Raisin pie is staple of Amish culinary culture, often served at funerals....so it is viewed as a comfort food for sure. I love raisin pie. This pie is made by Countryside Bakery, a Mennonite-owned certified kitchen. I've sampled items from here before, and I love it all. So treat yourself to raisin pie!
Week of June 23 - E-Cloths and Amish Peach Butter
I was a little skeptical when E-Cloth first sent me these. After all, regulars here know that I love my paper towels. But E-Cloth has a wide following, apparently, among the Amish so I wanted to try them myself. Since they are reusable, they are environmentally friend. My verdict: they really do a great job of cleaning! Here's a link to their YouTube channel that describes how to use the cloths And you can order a nice starter pack off Amazon here!
Sticking with our peach theme this week, check out this amazing peach butter from Black Buggy. These products are made by the Amish of Arthur, Illinois and the quality is always super. Spread this on toast or have a peanut butter and peach butter sandwich!
Week of June 30, 2023 - Amish-themed gift basket, Oatmeal Whoopie Pies, and Shoofly Pie Bars
I love this product from Amish Buggy. These products all come from Amish manufacturers in Arthur, Illinois. This Amish gift basket allows people to enjoy Amish-themed products of all kinds from honey and syrup to candy.
Authentic OATMEAL Amish Whoopie Pies....oatmeal whoopie pies are my favorite, they remind me of Little Debbies...so good. These Oatmeal Whoopie Pies come to us from Bird-in-Hand Bakeshop in Lancaster County, PA.
Shoofly Bar Cookies from Mennonite-owned Countryside Bakery. I love the idea of a shoofly pie in a bar form, well, now here it is!
Week of 7-14-2023 - Cherry Jam, Strawberry Salsa, and Espresso Whoopies
All products from Amish Buggy are made by Amish cooks and craftsman in Arthur, Illinois, which is why I love their stuff so much. But Cherry Jam? I am not a huge cherry fan, but I have tried this jam and it is amazing on toast or as part of a PB&J, you just don't find cherry jam a lot. But you can find it here!
Another entry from Amish Buggy: strawberry salsa. Eat this with some tortilla chips and you get this super blend of sweet and salty. Try it, you'll love it!
From the great state of Illinois: Espresso/Mocha flavored whoopie pies. What a super twist on a classic. Check them out!
July 21, 2023: Zucchini Relish, Black Walnut Fudge, and a Painting
Check out this seasonal specialty from Byler's Relish House. All items from there are authentically Amish and what better topping for a hot dog or summer hamburger than fresh zucchini relish! Get some here.
All of the "Black Buggy's" products are Amish-made in Arthur, Illinois. And check out this seasonal favorite: homemade black walnut fudge. Super! Get some fudge here.
I love this painting by a Kentucky artist. It is true that Amish life - and laundry - can be much more colorful than this, but the stark blacks and whites in this painting convey the Amish image of simplicity. I love it! You can order one here.
Week of July 28 - Ben's Amish Pretzels/Ben's Amish Cinnamon Rolls
There is something about pretzels and the Amish. Auntie Anne has her pretzel dogs. Annie Beiler (Auntie Anne) was raised in the Mennonite faith and began selling her homemade pretzels from a farmers market. An Amish man named Ben has enjoyed similar success, selling his pretzels from a cart and now he has a chain of pretzel kiosks. I sure wish they'd come to Ohio. Well, now they can - you can order pretzel making kits. You can order one here!
And if Ben's Pretzels aren't enough, you can order your own Ben's Cinnamon Roll kit. Pretty cool. Click here for your own cinnamon roll kit! Nothing like Amish melt-in-your-mouth cinnamon rolls! Just add water and follow the instructions.
Week of August 11 - Shipshewana Happy Salt and Amish Sweet Potato Butter, Pumpkin Pecan Butter, and Pumpkin Butter!
Follow the taste buds and seasoning sense of some of the Amish in northern Indiana. This "Happy Salt" is a super seasoning on, well, just about anything. I've had some and it is addictive, I love it on burgers, pork chops, in soups, etc, just really a flavor enhancer!
You'll love these new offerings from Amish Wedding Foods...Sweet Potato Butter, Pecan Pumpkin Butter, and Pumpkin Butter. Check them out here and, yeah, sweet potato butter on biscuits is amazing!