Home » Recipes

Top Amish Recipes

It’s been fun to watch which recipes rise to the top of Amish365’s rankings. You’d think the top recipe would be an Amish classic like shoofly pie or basic bread, but that’s never been there case. There’s  slow movement in recipes.  I remember for a couple of years after 2010,  Amish “Marriage Meatloaf” racked up the rankings.   Then it was doughnuts.   And then, wow, oh wow, Beautiful Broccoli Salad seemed everywhere.   Now it’s sour milk cake and brown sugar frosting   What will the future hold in terms of recipes ready for the top?  That’s up to you.  “Pandemic Baking” is has been popular in 2020 when COVID sent everyone into their kitchens.  Check back here often for our Top Recipes and learn everything you want to know about Amish culture!